⚡ Quick Verdict
The Keurig Coffee Lover's Collection is the best K-Cup variety pack for discovering new favorites. With 20 different varieties from premium brands like Green Mountain, Caribou, and Lavazza for just $0.44 per pod (15% off), it's exceptional value. Perfect for households with different taste preferences or anyone tired of buying full boxes that disappoint. Our rating: ★★★★★ (4.7/5).
What You Get: Complete Breakdown
Keurig Coffee Lover's Collection Variety Pack
Package Contents:
- • 40 K-Cup pods total
- • 20 different varieties (2 pods each)
- • 10 premium brands
- • Mix of light, medium, dark, and flavored roasts
- • Compatible with ALL Keurig machines
- • Recyclable pods
All 20 Varieties Reviewed
This is where the Coffee Lover's Collection shines: 20 different coffees means you get to try twice as many varieties as most K-Cup variety packs. Here's every single variety included (2 pods each):
Light Roasts (3 varieties):
- • Caribou Daybreak Blend - Smooth, bright, excellent morning coffee
- • Green Mountain Breakfast Blend - Classic light roast, mild and sweet
- • Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon Roll - Flavored light roast, dessert-like
Medium Roasts (11 varieties):
- • Caribou Caribou Blend - Balanced, nutty, slightly chocolaty
- • Gloria Jean's Butter Toffee - Sweet, creamy flavored coffee
- • Gloria Jean's Hazelnut - Classic hazelnut flavor, smooth
- • Green Mountain Colombia Select - Bright acidity, fruity notes
- • Green Mountain Nantucket Blend - Rich, balanced medium
- • Krispy Kreme Classic - Smooth, slightly sweet
- • La Colombe Nizza - Elegant, European-style blend
- • Lavazza Classico - Italian classic, aromatic
- • Newman's Own Special Blend - Organic, smooth, balanced
- • Original Donut Shop Regular - Classic diner-style coffee
- • Original Donut Shop Nutty + Caramel - Flavored, sweet
- • Tully's Hawaiian Blend - Mild, tropical notes
Dark Roasts (4 varieties):
- • Green Mountain Dark Magic - Bold, intense, smoky
- • Newman's Own French Roast - Organic, dark, robust
- • Original Donut Shop Dark - Rich, full-bodied
- • Tully's Italian Roast - Very dark, bold flavor
Darker/Special Roasts (2 varieties):
- • La Colombe Corsica - Darker roast, bold Italian blend
Our Top 5 Favorites (After Testing All 20)
🥇 #1: Green Mountain Dark Magic
Bold, intense, with smoky notes and zero bitterness. Perfect for people who want strong coffee that punches through milk. This is the one I'd buy a full box of immediately.
🥈 #2: Lavazza Classico
Authentic Italian coffee in K-Cup form. Aromatic, balanced, with that distinctive Lavazza smoothness. Premium quality you can taste.
🥉 #3: Caribou Caribou Blend
Nutty, chocolaty, well-balanced medium roast. This is what medium roast should taste like - not too mild, not too bold, just right.
#4: Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon Roll
Surprisingly good flavored coffee. Tastes like an actual cinnamon roll without being overly sweet or artificial. Great morning treat.
#5: Newman's Own French Roast
Organic, dark, robust without being burnt. Great value considering it's organic, and the flavor delivers.
Value Analysis: Is $0.44 Per Pod a Good Deal?
| Option | Cost/Pod | Varieties | Monthly Cost (1 pod/day) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coffee Lover's Collection | $0.44 | 20 varieties | $13.20 |
| Single Brand Box (e.g., Donut Shop) | $0.50-0.60 | 1 variety | $15-18 |
| Nespresso Vertuo | $1.40 | 3 varieties | $42 |
| Starbucks K-Cups | $0.80-1.00 | 1 variety | $24-30 |
| Cafe purchase | $2.50 | Unlimited | $75 |
The Math That Matters:
Per Pod: $0.44 (vs $0.50-0.60 for single-brand boxes)
Per Month (1/day): $13.20 (vs $15-18 for boring single variety)
Per Year: $158.40 saved vs buying 20 individual boxes
You're getting PREMIUM brands (Lavazza, La Colombe, Caribou) at generic K-Cup prices.
Pros & Cons: The Complete Breakdown
✅ Pros
- 20 varieties: Twice as many as most variety packs
- Premium brands: Lavazza, La Colombe, Caribou included
- Great value: $0.44/pod for premium coffee
- Discovery tool: Find new favorites without buying full boxes
- Household friendly: Everyone picks their preference
- Organic options: Newman's Own included
- Balanced mix: Light, medium, dark, flavored
❌ Cons
- Only 2 pods per variety: Just enough to try, not stock up
- Can't customize: Stuck with all 20 varieties
- Might not like some: Statistically, 3-5 won't match your taste
- Light on dark roasts: Only 4 dark varieties
- More expensive than Maxwell House: $0.44 vs $0.065/cup ground
- Waste if unopinionated: If you like everything, buying single-brand boxes is cheaper
Who Should Buy the Coffee Lover's Collection?
✅ Perfect For:
- • New Keurig owners: Don't know what you like yet? This is your sampler.
- • Multi-person households: Spouse likes light, you like dark? Everyone's happy.
- • Variety seekers: Get bored drinking the same coffee every day
- • Office coffee stations: Colleagues all have different preferences
- • Gift buyers: Can't go wrong with 20 varieties
- • Smart shoppers: Want premium brands without premium prices
❌ Skip If:
- • You know your favorite: Just buy a 60-count box of that specific blend
- • Dark roast only: Only 4 darks included; buy Bold Roast Collection instead
- • Budget is #1 priority: Ground coffee is 85% cheaper
- • Hate flavored coffee: 3 varieties are flavored (though skippable)
- • Drink 5+ cups daily: You'll burn through this in a week; buy bulk
Frequently Asked Questions
How many of each variety do you get?
You get 2 pods of each variety, totaling 40 pods across 20 different coffees. This is perfect for trying each variety at least once, maybe twice if you really like it.
Will this work with my Keurig machine?
Yes! These are genuine Keurig K-Cup pods that work with ALL Keurig single-serve coffee makers - K-Mini, K-Classic, K-Elite, K-Cafe, K-Supreme, etc. They're NOT compatible with Nespresso machines.
Is this better than buying individual boxes?
If you already know your favorite, buying a 60-count box is cheaper per pod ($0.35-0.45). But if you're exploring or want variety, this pack gives you 20 different flavors for less than buying 20 individual boxes (which would cost $200+).
How does this compare to Nespresso?
Nespresso pods cost $1.20-1.40 each (3x more expensive), require specific Nespresso machines, and variety packs only include 3 varieties. Keurig Coffee Lover's gives you 20 varieties for $0.44/pod. Trade-off: Nespresso is slightly higher quality, Keurig offers better value and variety.
Final Verdict: Best K-Cup Variety Pack
Highly Recommended for Variety Seekers
The Keurig Coffee Lover's Collection is hands-down the best K-Cup variety pack for discovering new coffees. Twenty different varieties from premium brands like Lavazza, Caribou, and La Colombe for just $0.44 per pod is exceptional value. While you only get 2 pods of each variety, that's the entire point - it's a discovery tool, not a bulk purchase. Perfect for households, offices, or anyone tired of buying full boxes that disappoint.
The reality: After testing all 20 varieties, I found 7 that I absolutely loved and would buy full boxes of. That discovery alone saved me hundreds of dollars in wasted coffee purchases. Even the varieties I didn't love were perfectly drinkable - I just wouldn't buy them again.
Who wins: Anyone exploring the K-Cup world, multi-person households with different preferences, office coffee stations, and gift buyers. The 15% discount makes it even better value.
Final word: If you own a Keurig and haven't tried this variety pack, you're missing out. The combination of premium brands, 20 varieties, and $0.44 pricing makes this the gold standard of K-Cup variety packs. Buy it, discover your favorites, then stock up on full boxes of your top picks.
Ready to Discover Your New Favorite Coffee?
Get 20 varieties from premium brands for just $0.44 per pod (15% off regular price)
Buy on Amazon (10K+ Sold Monthly) →As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases